Tracing Stitches and Spinning Reflection
My project
Assignment prompt
The thesis of my essay is comparing the resemblances and dissimilarities of Stitches and Spinning in regards to both of the comics exploring the complex relationships between the authors mother’s. I argue that although there are similarities between the two, certain nuances in illustration and artistic choices allow David Small and Tillie Walden to tell their own unique narrative’s of how they navigated through tough familial relationships.
By tracing the comic pages before I started crafting my essay, I was able to visually process what I wanted to be said. This was really helpful during the creation process of my analysis because I had a more clear understanding of the similarities and differences that I could extract from both illustrations.
Writing this essay using an inductive style approach allowed me to jump right into what I wanted to say, instead of starting from a general claim and then trying to find ideas from there to expand upon.
I definitely feel like this assignment has allowed me to get in on this “secret language of comics”, as I looked for clues that consisted of panel length, framing, character positioning, and word choice that helped to push each comic’s narrative. I also feel like I better understand the authors choices for why they decided to use less panels during a certain moment or why they didn’t show a character’s facial expression after something was said after analyzing the pages. The single biggest insight that I’ve gained about the two books would be that in Stitches, intense facial expression is utilized to show how much a moment impacted David and in Spinning, the use of negative space and panel size is used to convey Tillie’s feelings of isolation and loneliness. These choices of illustration had not occurred to me as intentional until I traced and really analyzed each panel.