Final Reflection Letter
If the freshman chooses their First Year Writing class next year, I recommend taking the Secret Language of Comics. From my experience, this course not only introduced comics, a novel literary medium for me, through several class readings, but the various writing and sketching assignments also helped me grow in my writing. Through these assignments, I learned more about my advantages and disadvantages in writing. I also accumulated more skills and improved through the progression of one assignment to another.
The first major writing assignment in the class was the Literacy Narrative Part 1, a personal narrative in which we analyzed the experiences shaping our reading and writing process. For this assignment, I tried to incorporate every detailed experience, every book I read, and every writing I created. However, after rereading the essay several times and receiving the professor’s feedback, I realized that the paper is too compact with loosely connected information, making it lose focus. I was glad that the project has multiple parts, which inspired my wish to revise and improve on the idea based on the problems spotted. On the other hand, After the professor’s reminder in class, I paid particular attention to incorporating citations when I included quotes from other authors’ works.
The Tracing Stitches and Spinning assignment introduced me to several new skills while exposing a similar problem in my writing. Since the genre for this assignment differs from the first personal narrative, the audience, or the professor who makes the assignment, might expect to see an essay that displays more about one’s ability to analyze others’ works and less about one’s personal experiences. Thus, in comparison to having more freedom in structure for the personal essay, I used a more standard ABT (and, but, therefore) organization for this essay to more clearly analyze the similarities and differences between the two comics and expand on how their characteristics contribute to the works as a whole. In this genre of more academic writing, I also have to eliminate figurative language and attach to a more formal and interpretive style. In addition, this assignment also trained my visual thinking ability when I interpreted others’ graphic works to assemble my own essay. For example, I wrote in my essay how an increase in the number of panels on the page could “induce the readers’ curiosity. Also, the compact configuration might at the first glance give the audience a sense of quickened pace and intensified emotions. “, showing how I learned to infer the mental effects that specific structures of comics can elicit in the readers, which helped me understand the authors’ purpose when using certain structures. However, sometimes I found myself lacking in providing visual interpretations, which reveals a similar issue in my literacy narrative: crowding my essay with too many pieces of information but not providing a deep enough analysis for each of them. I compared multiple elements from the two comics, such as the panel sizes, the perspectives, and whether the authors drew out their imaginations. However, I sometimes merely contrasted how the authors utilized the elements visually on the surface without analyzing why the author had chosen to incorporate them, their effects on the readers, and how they contributed to the entire narrative. Similar to the Literacy Narrative Part 1, these flaws disclose the need to find a focus, condensing my essay into just a few points and providing profound interpretations for them.
The second part of my Literacy Narrative project gave me the opportunity to revise the loose and obscure structure of my essays. Learning from my mistakes in the previous draft and from the professor’s advice, I extracted certain parts of my experience and focused mainly on how moving from China to the US affected my process of reading and writing. Concentrating on one component of my experience allows me to organize how specific details have influenced me and to better conclude a theme or message that expands on that particular experience than when dealing with multiple loosely connected sections. Through this process, I also further realized how writing is indeed a long process involving numerous revisions to learn from and resolve past mistakes. I also obtained certain unexpected discoveries. Knowing how comics are a genre that differs mainly from alphabetical narratives and that the audience might expect them to be more attractive to read, I borrowed specific techniques from my class readings and past analytical assignments. For example, I varied my sample sizes to emphasize certain significant moments, a method that I learned from the book Spinning. Also, like how David Small designed Stitches, I drew out what happened at the moment and how I interpreted these moments in my own imagination. Aside from obtaining new techniques, I also discovered that, personally, this assignment was the most significant part of this course. Because English is my second language, visual mediums provide more accessible and more vivid ways to portray my ideas than alphabetical mediums. Thus, I found creating a comic more intriguing than writing an essay. Through this project, I tightened my narrative and discovered a new, more compelling medium to express my ideas.

Having fixated my narrative around a central experience in Literacy Narrative Part Two, I was able to incorporate a main theme and message after returning to the alphabetical form in Part Three of the narrative. When drawing the narrative in Part Two, I discovered how my evolution in reading and writing revolved around the central theme of communication. I noted this finding when revising my essay in part one and developed the theme that “the language barrier after moving to the US taught me how much value effective communication means to me, which inspired my growth in reading and writing.” I reorganized my experiences mainly around how my wish for communication has inspired me, through which I clarified the structure of the essay and interconnected the initially separated parts about reading and writing. The Literacy Narrative project taught me how writing improves by revising problems and concentrating on the highlights. Still, it also enhanced my knowledge about personal narratives, that they can convey specific lessons and messages through descriptions of personal experiences.
This class not only allowed me to accumulate new skills but also exposed many problems I intend to focus on improving in the future. I organized my Halfa Kucha presentation the same way I would format a regular essay, and I did not pay particular attention to how I would arrange the pictures on the slides. However, after viewing my peers’ works, I recognized how insufficient my project was. Some of my peers started with a relatively shallow claim and then profoundly investigated the characters’ mentality as their presentations progressed. At the same time, others organized their slides in constructed ways, such as circling the emphasis or incorporating symbols. Many also included speech-like tones and gestures even under the pressing time limit. Their outstanding works showed me how presentations, as a different genre than essays, adopt a specific structure and tone. I also realized it takes a lot of time to practice presenting my ideas efficiently.
In addition, I also found myself needing more knowledge about how to use others’ works correctly. I learned from many sketch assignments that I can not simply search for images on Google and use them for my use. Instead, there are certain websites filled with public domain images. When searching for images for my ECS presentation, I used these websites rather than searching on Google.
Overall, I am glad this course guided me through my first year. Not only did I accumulate multiple skills, but most importantly, the class taught me through various assignments that writing is a process of exploration and growth. Through practice and drafting, I spot my issues and improve them; by exploring novel mediums, I identify my advantages and shortcomings. It is a course that elevates my interest and knowledge in writing.








